Asked about, didn't make the cut
Twelve things people bring up constantly, what is claimed, what the evidence shows, and why each isn't in the guide.
Scroll sideways to see every column →
| Entry | What people claim | What the evidence shows | Why it's not in the guide |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tormentil (refs 157–158) | A European herb that calmed one small UC series completely | One open-label study of 16 UC patients: clinical index and CRP improved and reversed when it was stopped. A 2020 Planta Medica review: traditional use supported by lab and animal data; clinical studies insufficient. | No US practitioner product on Fullscript as of this edition; a European pharmacopoeia herb. If one appears with a clean label, it would be a candidate for a later edition. |
| Visbiome / VSL#3 (refs 155–156) | The probiotic with the best IBD evidence | True, multiple positive RCTs in UC and in pouchitis prevention and maintenance. Strain-specific, high-dose multi-strain formulation. | Sold direct by the manufacturer and through pharmacies; not on Fullscript as of this edition. I would welcome a relationship with the company; it would be in the 100 if I could link it. Visbiome and VSL#3 are now different products: the original formulation moved to Visbiome in 2016, and the cited studies used that formulation. |
| Thymosin alpha-1 | An immune-modulating peptide that "resets" immunity | Real immunomodulatory evidence; approved as a drug in some countries. No IBD trials. | A prescription peptide (approved as a drug in some countries, not in the US), not a supplement, and not on Fullscript. I am interested in identifying a reputable, lawful source for people whose physicians prescribe it, which is a different thing from recommending it. |
| Clostridium butyricum MIYAIRI 588 | A butyrate-producing probiotic with clinical data | Japanese clinical data exist for this specific strain. | Strain not available in the US; generic C. butyricum appears only in multi-strain blends, not the studied product. |
| Human milk oligosaccharides (2'-FL) | The prebiotic in breast milk, for adults | Bifidogenic in small adult trials; IBS pilot data; no IBD trials. | Newer category with spotty practitioner distribution. Watch list. |
| Neem | Antimicrobial, anti-inflammatory Ayurvedic herb | Antimicrobial activity is real. Zero IBD evidence. Documented antifertility effects in both sexes; contraindicated in pregnancy and conception. | Available on Fullscript, excluded on safety, an IBD population skews young and female of childbearing age. |
| Oyster mushroom | One of the medicinal mushrooms | Some β-glucan and anti-inflammatory data, the weakest of the seven mushrooms considered. Widely eaten as a food across Asia and Europe, and one of the most cultivated mushrooms in the world. | Standalone products are uncommon; eat it as food. The other six mushrooms are in Section C. |
| Wheatgrass | Juice that heals UC | One small randomized UC trial (juice, 4 weeks) with improvement in rectal bleeding. Nothing since. | Weakest item considered for the anti-inflammatory section; a single small trial two decades old isn't enough for an entry, and I have not seen good effects with wheatgrass in my own work. |
| Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG | The best-known probiotic strain | Excellent data in antibiotic-associated and infectious diarrhea. In IBD the trials are mostly negative, including a pediatric Crohn's maintenance trial. | Widely used, IBD data mostly negative. Popularity isn't evidence. |
| Grapefruit seed extract | A natural antimicrobial | Commercial products have repeatedly been found adulterated with synthetic preservatives (benzethonium chloride and others); the antimicrobial activity tracks the adulterant. | You cannot recommend a product whose active ingredient is the contaminant. |
| Black walnut | Anti-parasitic | No IBD evidence of any kind. Appears only in "parasite cleanse" blends. | Nothing to evaluate. |
| Mucin | Replace the mucus layer directly | The theory is sound, the mucus layer is genuinely dysfunctional in IBD. Evidence that swallowing mucin helps is not there; it is a large protein and is digested. | Good theory, no supplement evidence. The mucin precursors (NAG (F-06) and phosphatidylcholine (F-08)) are in the guide instead. |
How the hundred were chosen
Four tests, in order. Is there a clean, single-ingredient product on Fullscript, or a food that makes a product unnecessary? Is there at least one human study in IBD, or a strong mechanism with human data in an adjacent condition, and an honest evidence bar to print beside it? Is the safety profile one I would accept for a client of mine, with the interactions and cautions known? And have I taken it, or watched it work or fail, in ten years in this community? Everything in the hundred passes the first three and most of it passes the fourth. Everything on this page fails at least one, and the right-hand column says which.
What a "no" means here
Not that a thing is worthless. Visbiome has the best pouchitis evidence of any probiotic; I simply cannot link you to it. Neem is on Fullscript and works as an antimicrobial; I will not recommend a herb with documented antifertility effects to a population that skews young and female. Wheatgrass has one real trial, from 2002, and one trial is not a shelf. A "no" here is a reason, printed, that you can disagree with. That is the standard I would want from anyone recommending me a bottle.
Brands I respect
Five companies doing something I think matters, none of them on my dispensary, named out of respect and an openness to future collaboration, not as an endorsement of everything they sell. Evinature (CurQD, curcumin with Qing Dai under gastroenterologist supervision; Dr. David T. Rubin, University of Chicago, sits on its advisory board). Vinia (whole red grape cells as a food-first source of the grape polyphenols behind C-06). GIVOL (the L-theanine spray I take; no spray exists on Fullscript, so M-03 links to a capsule). Visbiome (the best-evidenced high-potency probiotic in UC and pouchitis; sold direct, so it sits in the closing table). Lineage Provisions (Paul Saladino and Anthony Gustin's animal-based company, for taking nutrient-dense whole foods seriously; I have not evaluated a specific product, and a beef-organ complex is a candidate for a later edition, not one of the hundred). On CBD: I would name a company whose products carry a printable certificate of analysis and ship lawfully, and I have not found one since the hemp law changed. On peptide companies: interested, watching, not naming anyone yet.
READ & SHOP
Explore related supplements
Barrier Repair
N-acetylglucosamine (NAG)
The amino sugar the gut uses to build mucin, the mucus layer itself. In a London pilot, 8 of 12 children with severe, treatment-resistant IBD improved on NAG (oral,…
Barrier Repair
Phosphatidylcholine
The phospholipid that makes up most of the colonic mucus layer, and is measurably depleted in UC. A delayed-release PC (LT-02) had three positive Heidelberg trials…
The Five
Curcumin
Curcumin is the yellow pigment of turmeric root and the most-studied plant compound in inflammatory bowel disease. It has randomized trials in ulcerative colitis, a…
Options to explore with your care team. These are not a recommendation to take them together. Andrew earns a commission on Fullscript purchases. US shipping only.





