THE ONLINE GUIDE · VERSION 7.2

Food first, and why my score is a dash

Section J · Vitamins & Minerals · food first, then the form

Food first, and why my score is a dash

The previous page drew where each nutrient crosses into you. This page is about how to think before you buy: nutrient-dense food first, a lab value before a bottle, and the forms that make a difference once a bottle is warranted.

A watercolor of the digestive tract: stomach in ochre, small intestine in coral, colon in plum View full illustration ↗
Eat the nutrient firstLiver, red meat, clams and broth for iron and B12; leafy greens and lentils for folate; nuts, seeds and pumpkin seeds for magnesium and zinc; fatty fish and egg yolk for vitamin D; fermented and leafy foods for vitamin K. A nutrient-dense diet corrects most mild shortfalls on its own, and the food comes with the cofactors the capsule leaves out.
Test, then decide with your teamFerritin and a blood count for iron, serum B12 with methylmalonic acid if the value is borderline, 25-hydroxyvitamin D, and red-cell or serum folate and zinc where symptoms suggest them. A number tells you whether repletion is needed and lets you see it work; a guess does neither. Never take iron without a ferritin.
Where the anatomy matters. Crohn's most often inflames the ileum, so B12, bile acids and the fat-soluble vitamins are the first casualties, and a resection there makes the loss permanent. Ulcerative colitis lives in the colon, where water, potassium and the bacterial short-chain fatty acids are lost. The map on the previous page shows the rest.

Why I do not score every vitamin

A score in this guide is my judgment of what a supplement does for IBD. A vitamin you are deficient in does not need my judgment; it needs a lab value, and the score would be a 5 for one person and irrelevant for the next. So the individual vitamins and minerals carry evidence bars and a dash for my score, which means "no personal opinion applies here," not a zero. The multivitamin (J-00) carries the one score in the section, a 4: repletion insurance, taken every second or third day so it does not overdo the B12 or the fat-soluble vitamins.

The forms that matter here

B6 as pyridoxal-5-phosphate (P5P) rather than ordinary pyridoxine hydrochloride, a view I generally share with the practitioners who advise it; the O.N.E. multivitamin's label, checked for this edition, gives 4 mg of B6 with 38% of it as P5P and the rest as pyridoxine HCl, so it partly meets that preference, and the standalone P5P 50 (J-14) exists for people who want the active form alone; a form preference is not a reason to take more of it. Folate as methylfolate. B12 as methylcobalamin, in the amount your team and your absorption dictate. Iron as a bisglycinate chelate, never ferrous sulfate in a sore gut. Magnesium as glycinate, the form least likely to loosen stool. (ref 208)

READ & SHOP

Explore related supplements

Browse all 100 →

Vitamins & Minerals

Vitamin B12

Absorbed only in the terminal ileum, so ileal Crohn's and resection make deficiency likely. A Dutch RCT found extra B12 does not relieve fatigue in people who…

Evidence 3/5Andrew —/5

Vitamins & Minerals

Iron

Iron deficiency is the most common deficiency in IBD; European guidelines call for a blood count, ferritin and CRP every three months in active disease and every…

Evidence —/5Andrew 4/5

Options to explore with your care team. These are not a recommendation to take them together. Andrew earns a commission on Fullscript purchases. US shipping only.